Article: Do MBA graduates make the best leaders?


Do MBA graduates make the best leaders?

New research from DDI looks at different undergraduate and graduate-level degrees and how they translate into leader skills and performance.
Do MBA graduates make the best leaders?

While MBA graduates do make better managers, the same could not be said for their impact on stronger leadership


The Master of Business Administration (MBA) has become the most popular degree among graduate students with hundreds of thousands of students graduating each year, according to the latest figures from the U.S. Department of Education. The cost for these degrees can be up to $100,000 or more at top universities and companies pay a premium for those who have them—on average, about 36% more than a candidate with a bachelor’s level business degree with a similar level of experience. 

But there is limited research on how these degrees translate into leadership skills. It is also understood that many qualities cannot be “taught” in the classroom setting. Thus the question remains, do MBA graduates make the best leaders?

The scientists at Development Dimensions International (DDI), a global leadership development consultancy, examined how educational degrees translate into leadership skills in a new report, High-Resolution Leadership. The research is based on 15,000 leaders across 300 companies and 18 countries who participated in assessment center evaluations over the last nine years. The research found that when it comes to the full range of leadership skills required in today’s complex business environment, an MBA may not always be the best choice, according to lead author Evan Sinar, Ph.D., DDI’s Chief Scientist and Director, Center for Analytics and Behavioral Research. “MBA degrees did indeed make better managers,” said Sinar. “Unfortunately, the same couldn’t be said for their impact on stronger leadership.”

DDI’s research compared the performance of undergraduate business degrees and MBA degree holders against eight leader skills: financial acumen, business savvy, compelling communication, driving execution, driving for results, entrepreneurship, influence and inspiring excellence. These two groups diverged on several key leader skills. Specifically, though MBA graduates consistently outperformed business degree undergraduates in financial acumen, business savvy and strategic decision making, they fell short comparatively in their coaching, results orientation and visionary leadership skills. 

“While management skills are consistently higher for MBA graduates, we were surprised to find there are several skills that are lower,” Sinar said. “These are significant shortcomings when you consider the cost of the investment,” he added. 

“The research demonstrates that MBA students need more well-rounded background and experiences to learn the important interaction and inspirational skills they will need to truly excel as leaders,” said Sinar. “These skills are developable with sustained focus, but can’t be learned in an academic classroom. Skills practice with employees, expert coaching/mentoring and abundant on-the-job application opportunities are critical to make these challenging skills stick,” he said.

Which undergraduate degrees produce the best leaders? 

Skills of MBA compared to undergraduate degree holders

Educational degrees are closely linked to leadership capabilities and compensation levels for more than a decade into a professional’s career. So, whether a job candidate is looking for a first job or moving up into the leadership ranks, hiring managers and recruiters will make assumptions about candidates based on educational degrees.

According to Sinar, educational degrees both inform and mislead potential employers about leadership skills at the same time. Business degrees are the most common among all senior leaders and, when tested against eight key leadership competencies, outperformed other degrees on five of eight key leadership skill areas. Humanities graduates also outperformed other degrees through strengths not only in interpersonal competencies, but also in results orientation and entrepreneurship. Engineering graduates face a heavy disadvantage, they were near the bottom in leadership proficiency in six of the eight assessed competencies. Natural science, social science and IT were near average.  

“Our advice for graduates with degrees that are missing key leadership skills is to supplement coursework with hands-on opportunities through targeted learning programs and developmental assignments,” said Sinar. “A job candidate with the skills that his/her degree counterparts lack will have to recognize that assumptions may be made about his/her lack of leadership skills. For them, it will be particularly important to find ways to demonstrate these capabilities to overcome hiring biases—and to differentiate yourself from others holding the same degree, to gain an advantage in the job hunt.”

Balance Technical Expertise and Interpersonal Skills

The report found that Engineering, law, IT, and natural sciences graduates are particularly likely to fall behind their peers from other degree backgrounds in leadership skills. This isn’t always a problem when graduates start out at a new job as an individual contributor, but can hold them back when they want to move into a management position. For aspiring leaders, it’s important to strike a balance between the critical technical expertise that most undergraduate degrees provide, with an awareness of common skill gaps that, if left unchecked, will limit overall leadership effectiveness and career mobility. 

Many degree programs put a heavier focus on developing graduates’ technical abilities, and much less emphasis on interpersonal and leadership skills. Though some degree programs fill this gap with group projects and informal leadership opportunities, it’s often up to the student to plan for and seek out these opportunities. It’s also a way to set a candidate apart from the pack of other graduates in the field, if they have put the time and effort into gaining the skills others lack. 

Sinar’s advice: “Get as much information as you can—using your career planning office if you’re still in school, or working with your HR department once you’re in a job—to know your leadership-related strengths and weaknesses and invest in development opportunities to give you the skills you’ll need and plenty of time to practice them before you need them.”

Read DDI’s full report and 18 individual findings.

Read full story

Topics: Leadership, Leadership Development, #Education

Did you find this story helpful?



How do you envision AI transforming your work?

Your opinion matters: Tell us how we're doing this quarter!

Selected Score :