Article: Men are favoured over women candidates by India Inc: Randstad Survey


Men are favoured over women candidates by India Inc: Randstad Survey

In the Randstad Workmonitor Survey, 70% male respondents from India mentioned that they prefer a male as a direct manager.
Men are favoured over women candidates by India Inc: Randstad Survey

While HR fraternity has been vocal about how diverse workplaces bring in better productivity – in business and performances of employees, what juxtaposes this intent is the Randstad Workmonitor Survey findings. 55% of the overall survey respondents from India indicated that men are favoured over women when two candidates are equally qualified for the same job at their workplace. 61% of the male respondents and 47% of the female respondents agreed to this statement, while globally 70% of the survey respondents stated this. Diversity is a distant reality for the Indian corporates, it seems.

Preferably, a Male manager

When asked for a preference, 70% of the male respondents from India mentioned that they prefer a male as direct manager and in reality, a vast majority (87%) actually have one currently. The figures deviate among women: only 41% of the female respondents prefer a male as direct manager and 50% actually have one currently. 

57% of the overall survey respondents from India had a male manager preference and a vast majority (70%) pointed out that currently, they work with a male manager. This was even higher than the global average of 67%, who said they currently work with a male superior. 

"It is a proven fact that diverse organizations perform better as this offers an assortment of knowledge and skills. An objective and ethical organizational philosophy that values an individual for the competencies they bring to the table is critical. After all, a country has truly evolved only when diversity in its true spirit is promoted across, with corporates setting the benchmarks, creating a conducive work environment for women. This will definitely help India reap rich rewards of economic growth as well," said Paul Dupuis, MD & CEO, Randstad India while presenting the survey insights,

Rewards are equal

Despite numerous reports highlighting the continuous gender pay gap, the study also found that a whopping 91% of the respondents from India believed that at their workplace, both men and women in similar roles were rewarded equally. This is much higher than the global average of 79%, who thought so. 88% also felt that both men and women are equally supported when asking for a promotion. 

In heading a team, 93% say that their direct manager plays an important role in setting the team spirit and 90% also agree that their direct manager advocates company culture and sets the example for the rest of the team members. 

Diversity is a key element in team performance

On a more positive note, team diversity was highly appreciated by all the employees globally, who were part of this study. 89% of the respondents from India said that they prefer to work in a gender-diverse team, while 86% believed that gender-diverse teams perform and achieve better results than single gender teams. And 61% consider it a good thing that one gender is favoured above the other in order to meet the diversity target. 84% also believed that gender equality increases with the seniority of the job. 

“Gender diversity may be high on the agenda for India Inc. today, but what I believe is that diversity is not just a goal or a guideline, it is a business imperative. All the corporate and government initiatives are just a start, the real change can happen only when we succeed in addressing the deep-rooted mind sets about the role of women at work,” said Paul. 

The Randstad Workmonitor was launched in the Netherlands in 2003, then in Germany, and now covers 33 countries around the world. The last country to join was Portugal in 2014. The study encompasses Europe, Asia Pacific, and the US. The Workmonitor’s Mobility Index, which tracks employee confidence and captures the likelihood of an employee changing jobs within the next 6 months, provides a comprehensive understanding of sentiments and trends in the job market. Besides mobility, the survey addresses employee satisfaction and personal motivation as well as a rotating set of themed questions.

The study is conducted online among employees aged 18-65, working a minimum of 24 hours a week in a paid job (not self-employed). Minimum sample size is 400 interviews per country. The Survey Sampling International (SSI) panel is used for sampling purposes. 

Read full story

Topics: Diversity

Did you find this story helpful?



How do you envision AI transforming your work?